Estimating with Tee Shirt Sizes

I occasionally encounter the use of t-shirt sizes (Small, Medium, Large, or so on) in use as estimating units by teams. T-shirt sizes are an OK approach to getting started with relative estimating, but they suffer from two severe weaknesses:

  • They aren't additive. You cannot tell a boss you'll be done in 3 mediums, 4 larges, and 2 petites.

  • Your view of an XL may not match mine. You may think it's 50% bigger than an L; I may think 25% bigger.

Teams get around both weaknesses with some underlying assumptions (hopefully stated) about size. They may, for example, state, “Let's call a medium a 5 and a large a 10.”

The primary advantage to t-shirt sizes is the ease of getting started. If a team needs to start with t-shirt sizes, that's fine. Later, though, that team will be better off using numbers directly. I might forget that an XL is 33% bigger than an L. I won't forget that a 10 is twice a 5. (If I do, the team has a different problem!)

T-shirt sizes can be a great way of becoming accustomed to relative estimating. So, start with them if your team finds that easier. But minimally put some underlying numbers on them (e.g., Medium=5) and then gradually shift to using the numbers directly.

Agile Estimating and Planning Chapters
Download

Agile Estimating and Planning Chapters

Featured

Read sample chapters from Mike Cohn's Agile Estimating and Planning and explore practical guidance for estimating, planning, and forecasting agile work. Please provide your name and email and we’ll send you the…

An agile coach and team discussing their work together.
Coaching

Estimating & Planning

Featured

Improve estimates, forecasts, release planning, and conversations about scope, timing, and risk.

Video

Learning from an Experiment in Estimating

Featured

Explore Learning from an Experiment in Estimating in this Mountain Goat Software video.

Video

Scrum Success: Estimating Product and Sprint Backlogs in Teams

Explore Scrum Success: Estimating Product and Sprint Backlogs in Teams in this Mountain Goat Software video.

Article artwork for 7 Ways to Get the Best Estimates of Story Size.
Article

7 Ways to Get the Best Estimates of Story Size

Agile teams often struggle to estimate product backlog items. Here are 7 ways to make solid improvements.

Plan Visualizer
Tool

Plan Visualizer

The Plan Visualizer is a free agile forecasting tool for testing whether a target scope can be completed by a target deadline. It plots the plan against a low and high velocity estimate so teams and stakeholders can…